62-blue_sm2012 wwj950-sm2011b 971-ticket-35smb 35h_CBSSportsRad_Detroit

Local

Michigan Rep. Censored For Use Of ‘V-Word’

View Comments
(credit: istock)

(credit: istock)

timskubick

Reporting Tim Skubick

LANSING (WWJ) - A West Bloomfield state representative has been censored for comments she made during a House of Representatives session.

Reporting live on WWJ Newsradio 950, Lansing Bureau Chief Tim Skubick, called it a “certified freedom of speech issue.”

Skubick said Rep. Lisa Brown, a Democrat, was told by House Republican leaders she could not participate in debate Thursday because she used the word “vagina” during a discussion about abortion legislation the day before.

Her words on the House floor Wednesday were: “And, finally, Mr. Speaker — I’m flattered that you’re so interested in my vagina, but no means no.”

In an interview with Skubick, Brown defended her comments.

“I used an anatomically correct word. I said ‘vagina.’ Is there something wrong with that? Can I not say ‘elbow? I don’t see what the difference is,” Brown said.

“If that is the problem, really … If you can’t talk and you can’t talk and you can’t use the word ‘vagina’ — why are you legislating about vaginas?”

A spokesperson for the House Speaker said it was “unprofessional conduct” and her “offensive comments” disrupted the decorum of the House.

Rep. Barb Byrum, a Democrat from Onondaga, was also gaveled down and reprimanded after she attempted to begin a debate on her amendment on the same issue.

“There were actions by Representative Byrum on the floor involving shouting in the chamber that also failed to maintain decorum,” said House Speaker spokesman Ari Adler.

WWJ spoke with Bobbie Walton, president of the Michigan chapter of the National Association for Women.

“I think the word ‘decorum’ and the word ‘professionalism’ are open-ended words. You can define them any way you want to,” Walton said. “One person’s decorum is perhaps another person’s gag order.”

Senate Democratic Leader Gretchen Whitmer of East Lansing and Senator Rebekah Warren or Ann Arbor, later Thursday, released a video message denouncing what they call “recent attacks on women made by the Republican-led legislature.”

“The war on women is unfortunately all too real and nowhere is that more evident than at the highest levels of Michigan’s government,” said Whitmer. “Republicans have proven beyond any measure that they are not only willing to play politics with the health of women throughout Michigan, but that they are willing to go so far as to take away our right to speak out for ourselves. The only question remaining is what’s next? Taking away women’s right to vote?” (View the video).

View Comments
  • http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2012/06/15/speakers-office-context-was-problem-with-reps-use-of-v-word/ Speaker’s Office: ‘Context’ Was Problem With Rep’s Use Of ‘V-Word’ « CBS Detroit

    [...] a Democrat, was told by House Republican leaders she could not participate in debate Thursday because she used the word “vagina” during a discussion about abortion legislation the day [...]

  • http://jeffoakes.me/2012/06/16/all-about-the-vagina-to-the-michigan-state-legislature-warning-graphic/ All About the Vagina…to the Michigan State Legislature (warning, graphic) « Jeff Oakes

    [...] Michigan Rep. Censored For Use Of ‘V-Word’ (detroit.cbslocal.com) [...]

  • http://mattbors.com/blog/2012/06/18/the-avenging-uterus/ The Avenging Uterus | Bors Blog

    [...] “And, finally, Mr. Speaker — I’m flattered that you’re so interested in my vagina, but no means no.” – Michigan State Rep. Lisa Brown [...]

  • http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2012/06/18/vagina-protest-staged-in-lansing-with-help-from-famous-playwright/ ‘Vagina Protest’ Staged In Lansing With Help From Famous Playwright « CBS Detroit

    [...] Michigan recitation is a protest aimed at Republicans who censured Democratic state Rep. Lisa Brown for using the word “vagina” in the House of Republicans during an abortion debate. Her [...]

  • http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2012/06/18/protest-at-capitol-drawing-support-from-both-sides-of-the-isle/ Protest At Capitol Drawing Support From Both Sides Of The Isle « CBS Detroit

    [...] the anatomically correct word got (D) State Rep. Lisa Brown banned from speaking on the House Floor for two days last [...]

  • http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2012/06/18/suppression-of-free-speech-at-core-of-v-day-rally/ Suppression Of Free Speech At Core Of V-Day Rally « CBS Detroit

    [...] of the “Vagina Monologues” was there along with the two state representatives who were silenced on the House Floor for their remarks on the issue of [...]

  • http://elcafetindelas5.com/2012/06/20/el-mundo-que-odia-a-las-mujeres/ El mundo que odia a las mujeres – El Cafetín de las 5

    [...] fueran algo sucio, vergonzoso, casi mitológico (en Estados Unidos se censura el uso de la palabra “vagina” en debates sobre el [...]

  • http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2012/06/26/silenced-lawmaker-gets-huge-outpouring-of-support/ Silenced Lawmaker Gets Huge Outpouring Of Support « CBS Detroit

    [...] Michigan Rep. Censored For Use Of ‘V-Word’ [...]

  • http://www.reclaimingpink.com/aborting-the-argument-something-that-both-camps-would-agree-on/ Aborting the Argument: Something that Both Camps Would Agree On | Reclaiming Pink

    [...] are all questions that must be drawn into focus rather than cast into the shadows by unproductive political debates where one our very few elected women are censured for using an anatomically correct word for a [...]

  • http://alphawriter.wordpress.com/2012/07/12/did-you-miss-me/ Did you miss me? | alphawriter

    [...] I have neglected Blogging however, and I am getting back to it. Boy do I have some doozies; how about a certain Congressman censoring a Congresswoman for using the word Vagina… The republican house actually said Rep, Lisa Brown was “Unprofessional” for using the word… Sounds like somebody needs to grow up, just sayin’. Yes genius it’s old news it happened in June, I’m just getting around to it :p Click here for the report from CBS [...]

  • http://writinginthewild.com/2012/08/29/calling-all-white-people/ Calling All White People | writinginthewild.com

    [...] under obscenity laws, just as they did Sanger? Not too long it seems. One Congresswoman, Lisa Brown, has already been slapped on the wrist for mentioning her vagina in a public debate about [...]

  • http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2012/12/12/senate-approves-anti-abortion-bills-in-michigan/ Senate Approves Anti-Abortion Bills In Michigan « CBS Detroit

    [...] this year, two Democratic lawmakers were disciplined by Republican leaders for saying “vagina” and “vasectomy” while discussing the legislation on the House floor.  Senate Democratic leader Gretchen Whitmer [...]

  • http://localdetroitnews.com/news/senate-approves-anti-abortion-bills-in-michigan/ Senate Approves Anti-Abortion Bills In Michigan | Local Detroit News

    [...] this year, two Democratic lawmakers were disciplined by Republican leaders for saying “vagina” and “vasectomy” while discussing the legislation on the House floor.  Senate Democratic leader Gretchen Whitmer [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Follow CBS Detroit

Like us on foursquare

Top Talkers

Select a Live Stream