UM-Northwestern Advance In Measuring Toxic Metals Cheaply
ANN ARBOR – A strip of glass covered in hairy nanoparticles can cheaply and conveniently measure mercury, which attacks the nervous system, and other toxic metals in fluids.
Researchers at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Northwestern University and the University of Michigan found that their new method can measure methylmercury, the most common form of mercury pollution, at unprecedentedly small concentrations. The system, which could test for metal toxins in drinking water and fish, is reported in the current edition of Nature Materials.
Methylmercury is formed from inorganic mercury by the action of anaerobic organisms that live in aquatic systems. It bioaccumulates up the food chain, reaching its highest levels in large, predatory fish like tuna and swordfish. There is dispute between environmental groups and the fishing industry whether methylmercury pollution is man-made or naturally occurring, with fishing industry groups citing peer-reviewed scientific studies showing high levels of mercury in deep ocean fish that are 90 years old — and thus would not have been exposed to much recent mercury pollution — and studies showing the level of mercury in fish has actually declined since the 1970s. Also, a California appeals court ruled in 2009 that the fishing industry had proven that mercury in canned fish was naturally occurring. But there is no doubt that methylmercury is a potent reproductive toxin that can harm a developing fetus, and the primary path for human exposure to methylmercury is consumption of fish. For this reason, the FDA and EPA advise women who may become pregnant, pregnant women, nursing mothers and young children not to eat shark, swordfish, king mackerel or tilefish at all, and to limit to two meals a week “a variety of fish and shellfish that are lower in mercury,” including “shrimp, canned light tuna, salmon, pollock, and catfish.”
Methylmercury in fish isn’t consistently measured, and there have been frequent alerts from environmental groups about mercury in canned tuna and fish used in sushi.
“The problem is that current monitoring techniques are too expensive and complex,” said researcher Francesco Stellacci, the Constellium Chair holder at EPFL. “With a conventional method, you have to send samples to the laboratory, and the analysis equipment costs several million dollars.”
Using the device invented by the Swiss-American team, measuring the mercury levels in water or dissolved fish meat is as simple as dipping a strip of coated glass into the fluid. Metals and metallic molecules, such as methyl mercury, typically become positively charged ions in water. When these ions drift between the hairy nanoparticles, the hairs close up, trapping the pollutant. Passing a current over the strip of glass reveals how many ions are caught in the “nano-velcro.” Each ion allows the strip to conduct more electricity.
UM researchers Hao Jiang and Sharon Glotzer, the Churchill Professor of Chemical Engineering, performed computer simulations that investigated how the nano-velcro traps pollutants. They showed that the hairy nanoparticles are choosy about which ions they capture, confirming that the strips can give reliable measures of specific toxins as demonstrated by the experimental findings of the Swiss group.
“By making detection of pollutants and toxins cheap and easy to do, more testing at the source will lead to safer foods on the dinner table and in kids’ lunchboxes, ” Glotzer said.
The scientists targeted particular pollutants by varying the length of the nano-hairs. This approach is especially successful for methyl mercury, and the device can measure it with record-breaking accuracy, detecting concentrations as low as 600 methyl mercury ions per cubic centimeter of water. Fortunately, that level of precision won’t break the bank. The researchers estimate that the coated glass strips could cost less than 10 dollars each, while the measurement device will cost only a few hundred dollars. It could gauge the concentration of metals onsite and within minutes.
The researchers tested their method in Lake Michigan, near Chicago.
“The goal was to compare our measurements to FDA measurements done using conventional methods,” Stellacci said.
Despite the industrial activity in the region, mercury levels were extremely low, in agreement with the FDA’s analysis. The team also tested a mosquito fish from the Everglades.
“We measured tissue that had been dissolved in acid. The goal was to see if we could detect even very minuscule quantities,” said Bartosz Grzybowski, the K. Burgess Professor of Physical Chemistry and Chemical Systems Engineering at Northwestern University, noting the species is too low on the food chain to accumulate high levels of mercury.
The United States Geological Survey reported near-identical results after analyzing the same sample.
“With this technology, it will be possible to conduct tests on a much larger scale in the field, or even in fish before they are put on the market,” said researcher Hyewon Kim, MIT student visiting EPFL.
Funding for this research came from ENI, via the ENI-MIT Alliance; the U.S. Defense Threat Reduct ion Agency via a grant to MIT and UM; and the U.S. Department of Energy via a Nonequilibrium Energy Research Center grant to Northwestern and UM.