By f) Scott Anderson

This past weekend, William Gholston led the Spartan defense in a dominant performance over the Wolverines. Michigan State was able to effectively neuter Michigan by handling Denard Robinson for the second straight season in winning the Paul Bunyan Trophy for the fourth year in a row. State punched Michigan in the mouth literally and figuratively and in the end, it’s a punch in the mouth that’s getting all the attention instead of what really happened on the field which was a sound drubbing in our annual Civil War.

Yes, there were personal foul calls for roughing the quarterback and for throwing a punch, 6 calls I believe in all against Michigan State. Their aggressive play got over-aggressive at times and they were flagged accordingly. But, let’s not treat this like it was the most egregious, reprehensible play we’ve ever seen. It was football, hard nosed, smash mouth, football. One side will love it, the other will hate it. If the outcome were reversed, the only change would be about who is upset. We would still have one side begging for a Big Ten bailout in the form of a suspension.

I must say that all this talk about sportsmanship and dirty play is getting a bit tired. It seems that we have conveniently forgotten how much we love blood lust when it’s our team. Mike Valenti said it beautifully, “I would rather my team play like Suh than Susan.” Amen, brother! Remember him? Ndamukong Suh? He’s the guy who plays for the Lions and tried to decapitate Andy Dalton earlier this year, or go back to last year when he got a hold of Jake Delhomme. How many times has he been called for personal fouls? How many times in a game do we hear about personal fouls? It happens all the time, it’s football. We’ll celebrate it when it’s our guy and it doesn’t cost us a game. We’ll condemn it when it isn’t our guy or if there’s a loss attributed to the aggressive nature.

I am not condoning Gholston’s behavior regarding his twist off cap impression of Denard, which was cheap and uncalled for. As far as the punch was concerned, look at what preceded it. Taylor Lewan grabbed a hold of Gholston’s facemask and forced him to the ground; big Will took exception and threw a right hand that glanced off Lewan’s jaw and helmet. It’s not like Gholston grabbed Lewan’s junk, nor did he give a Ric Flair chop to his throat, it was a retaliatory punch. But, if you find it so ghastly and demand satisfaction in the form of a suspension, so be it.

I offer this stern warning, be careful of what you wish for as it may open Pandora’s Box. An awful lot goes on during the course of a football game that doesn’t get flagged. So while the disparity in personal foul calls looms large, it doesn’t mean the other side was singing in Church. When MSU AD Mark Hollis released his statement about the matter, he indicated that they will go over every bit of film, play by play, and still photographic evidence to make sure that they are properly prepared in submitting their findings before the Conference. That means they could uncover some other unsightly instances of poor sportsmanship. So, be ready Michigan fans, it’s easy to point the finger when you’re not looking in your own direction.

This isn’t intended to rile up the Michigan faithful, the reality is that Gholston probably will get suspended and that even though he was a beast on the field and the Spartans won, it could cost them dearly this Saturday night against the Badgers if he is held out of action. Hopefully Gholston has learned something from all of this; you have to keep your emotions in check even in the most emotional of games. It might say something about his character though when you realize that he was one of the few that went over to Brady Hoke to shake his hand after the conclusion of the game. I’d be curious to know what was said and how Hoke feels about the situation. I’ll bet he was wishing that he had big Will on his side and I don’t think he’s alone.

Comments (3)
  1. Don says:

    I hear all the talk about how WE cheer for Suh when he tries to decapatate a QB please speak for yourself . I think Suh is fantastic and love the fact that he is a Lion, but when he commited not only that penalty but others that he has done the first thing I always say is “WHAT A STUPID PLAY YOU KNOW THEY ARE GOING TO CALL THAT” I never say great play.

  2. Don says:

    The only reason Gholston went over to shake Hoke’s hand was to apoligize for what he had done in hopes Hoke would not push for a suspension

  3. Luke says:

    #1, you can’t compare college athletics with professional. That’s a stupid argument. To tell your student athletes that its win at all costs is disgusting. You (and Valenti) lose a lot of credibility if you can’t recognize the difference. I could create a list a mile long of past college programs that were ruined and disrespected for having that mentality. Does MSU really want to be the Miami Hurricanes of the late 80’s? I’m not saying that they are, just that they could be headed down that path if this behavior isn’t stopped. It appeared clear to me that the MSU defense was given a bounty for Robinson, and to knock him out of the game. Even in the fourth quarter, with victory all but certain for the Spartans, Marcus Rush suplexes Robinson on a late hit, this injures him enough to leave the game. They couldn’t knock him out with a clean hit, so they resorted to goonery (like the helmet twist). All the while, Spartan players were encouraging their hometown crowd to cheer while Robinson was being tended to on the field. Like they’d finally accomplished what they’d set out to do. Then the crowd booed him when he finally made it to his feet to leave the field. That is disgusting behavior for a college game.
    #2, Gholston fell down trying to spin-move around Lewan, and then Lewan held him down. Yes, Lewan MIGHT have grabbed his face mask to hold him down. MIGHT have. It’s not clear in the replay. But if he did, he had a hold of it for about one second, if that. Lewan may not be a saint, but he didn’t grab “a hold of Gholston’s facemask and forced him to the ground”. So stop saying that. You lose more credibility.
    #3, the investigation and possible suspension is more of a judgment of the officiating than anything else. Stop trying to diminish the punch. . . “It wasn’t an ax to the taint, or a You lose MORE credibility. No matter if you think it was justifiable retaliation or not, the rules are clear. You throw a punch, you’re out of the game. If the officials had ejected Gholston like they are obligated to do, there wouldn’t be this post game distraction.
    #4, guys intentionally trying to injury, possibly ending someone’s athletic career, suplexing after the play, punching, ripping guys face masks 90+ degrees while they lay on top of them, is not “smash mouth” college football. You sound ridiculous saying that.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Watch & Listen LIVE