DETROIT (WWJ/AP) – An inmate who won a groundbreaking case about the power of Michigan governors to change prison sentences has lost his bid for a parole review and won’t be considered again for five years, an official said Friday.
The 10-member parole board took a vote in July after Matthew Makowski was interviewed by chairman Michael Eagen, said Russ Marlan, a spokesman at the state Corrections Department.
“They pass around a voting form, and parole board members either sign their name under ‘interest to parole’ or ‘no interest to parole,”‘ Marlan told The Associated Press.
“In this case, the first six parole board members signed under ‘no interest to parole.’ At that point the voting was over since a majority could not be achieved,” he explained.
No reason was given. A vote in favor of Makowski could have led to a parole hearing, although state law also allows a judge to block the entire process.
Makowski’s attorney, Paul Reingold at University of Michigan law school, declined to comment. Attorney General Bill Schuette had urged the parole board to keep Makowski behind bars.
Makowski has been in prison since 1989 when he was convicted of first-degree murder for a robbery that turned into a fatal stabbing in Dearborn. Makowski wasn’t present when co-worker Pietro “Pete” Puma was killed but he had arranged the robbery.
Makowski, now 47, has been a model prisoner. In 2010, Gov. Jennifer Granholm commuted his no-parole sentence in one of her final acts as governor. But in an unprecedented move, she rescinded the order within 48 hours, on Christmas Eve, when the Puma’s family protested. Relatives said they were not told that Makowski was being considered for release and only read of the commutation in the news.
In June, the Michigan Supreme Court unanimously agreed that Granholm’s reversal was illegal, making Makowski eligible for parole.
Reingold, meanwhile, is still waiting for the Supreme Court to respond to his request to jump back into the case. He believes the commutation means Makowski should be automatically released from prison.
TM and © Copyright 2014 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2014 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.